Wetlands in Minnesota

Update

Don’t Eviscerate Clean Water Programs with the Permitting Reform Bill

There is a heated debate in the U.S. Congress revolving around how to streamline the permitting process for projects requiring a federal permit or license. That should not gut clean water protections.

By Nancy Stoner, Senior Attorney

There is a heated debate in the U.S. Congress revolving around how to streamline the permitting process for projects requiring a federal permit or license. The bill released by the Senate called the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA) is intended to build and modernize infrastructure, deploy cleaner energy, strengthen the electric grid and improve transportation systems.

While ELPC is a strong proponent of renewable energy development, ELPC is opposing BAAJA in its current form because: (1) the fossil fuel benefits are at least as substantial, and arguably greater than the renewable energy benefits, and (2) all of this comes at the severe cost of gutting core environmental standards and values in the Clean Water Act, Endangered Species Act, National Historic Preservation Act, and the National Environmental Protection Act.

Reasonable reforms that make permitting more efficient and speed the build out of our transmission system deserve serious consideration. But this bill does more harm than good. We can and must do better.

Let’s talk about the detrimental impacts of the clean water provisions in this bill.

The Clean Water Act (CWA) was passed in 1972 because the previous system in which every state had its own system for protecting clean water wasn’t working. The result was that the Cuyahoga River in Ohio was on fire, Lake Erie was declared dead, oil spills were occurring off the coast of Santa Barbara, and rivers and lakes nationwide were dumping grounds for every kind of pollution from industrial waste to sewage.

Congress passed the CWA to protect the biological, chemical, and physical integrity of waters and to stop all pollution discharges into waters by 1985 – very ambitious goals. It put in place several excellent programs to accomplish these goals including the effluent guidelines program to stop pollution from industrial sources and the construction grants program to build sewage treatment plants and drinking water plants across the country. While it has accomplished a tremendous amount in the 50+ years since it was passed, it hasn’t been enough to make all our waterways clean and safe to use. There is still work to do.

Poll after poll show that Americans across the political spectrum want the US to do more to ensure that waterways are clean and safe for use as drinking water sources, fishing, swimming, wildlife habitat, and for manufacturing and farming.

We should be strengthening the Clean Water Act, not weakening it.

The Trump administration has shown no interest in stopping water pollution; instead, it has proposed rules that would eliminate Clean Water Act protections for most of the streams and even more of the wetlands in the US and would drastically reduce the authority of states and Tribes to reject or place conditions that protect water quality on pipelines, dams and other projects that require a federal permit. If these proposals were on the ballot, they would be overwhelmingly rejected by the American public.

BAAJA would further erode clean water protections.

What would BAAJA do to clean water protections?

1) It would weaken the ability of states and Tribes to protect their waterways using their Section 401 certification authority. The bill would make it particularly difficult for states and Tribes to protect their waterways from pollution from the construction and operation of natural gas pipelines as well as the risk of leaks or, even worse, explosions. It means that the concrete pad that is put into a waterway to hold up the transmission line or the fill that is put into a river to support a gas pipeline would be subject to state and tribal review for its water quality impacts, but not the clearcutting, scars, runoff, and other aspects of the project that would impact water quality. For decades, states and Tribes have used this authority to safeguard drinking water sources, fisheries, wetlands, and aquatic habitat.

Most projects sail through the process with only minor modifications to minimize wetlands destruction or to control polluted construction site runoff.  But Section 401 can also be used by states and Tribes to prevent projects from moving forward that should never be built in the first place.

One recent example is the Confined Disposal Facility on the SE Side of Chicago on the shores of Lake Michigan. It is an almost-full toxic waste dump that would have had an additional waste dump built on top of it if the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers had succeeded in acquiring all the necessary permits. The new 25-foot-high facility would have polluted Lake Michigan with hazardous materials from dredged material from the nearby Calumet River and put another toxic hazard in an overburdened neighborhood on Chicago’s Southeast Side. ELPC used our legal and advocacy fire power and worked with environmental justice community leaders to convince Illinois not to grant the project a Section 401 certification along with other required permits. The Army Corps ultimately withdrew its permit applications, and soon the existing toxic waste dump will be capped off and turned into a lakefront park.

2) The bill would also weaken other crucial Clean Water Act provisions, like restricting the ability of EPA to stop projects that would destroy pristine wetlands.  An example is the Bristol Bay copper mine that would have decimated the largest sockeye salmon fishery in the US.

3) It would also use reissued general permits designed for small, routine projects to bypass endangered species and environmental impact reviews.  This would allow projects to move forward without individualized water quality reviews or public input.

It would also make it much more difficult for states and Tribes to ensure that federal hydropower dams are built so as to protect the fish that live in the rivers. It would even prevent EPA from updating science about PFAS and other emerging contaminants without a major federal rulemaking.

In conclusion.

The CWA provisions of the bill are just a wish list from the fossil fuel industry of clean water provisions that they would like to weaken because they require protection of water resources. While not particularly pertinent to the stated goals of this bill, these changes are very damaging to water resources and will be very difficult to undue if Congress passes them.  If you want to do a deep dive into the impact of the bad clean water provisions of this bill, read our fact sheets here.

Clean water is not partisan. Americans overwhelmingly support federal protections for clean water. They expect government at every level to protect the rivers, lakes and streams that supply drinking water and are a vital natural resource. Failing to protect the sources of our drinking water drives up costs for the utilities that provide our water, making water more expensive.

Permitting reform and clean water protection does not have to be in conflict. If Congress is serious about both, it should keep clean water protections out of the bargaining process on permitting reform. Weakening the CWA would do little for permitting efficiency and a great deal to increase the risk of water pollution. It’s a trade-off that all should reject.

Nancy Stoner

Nancy Stoner,

Senior Attorney

Nancy Stoner is a Senior Attorney with ELPC focused on clean water issues.

MORE FROM Nancy Stoner