Garden of the Gods in Shawnee National Forest, Illinois.


Tyler Barron

The Call of the Wild: Helping Protect Southern Illinois’ Natural Treasures

Famous for vistas like Garden of the Gods, the Little Grand Canyon, Panther Den and Inspiration Point, the Shawnee National Forest in Southern Illinois has no shortage of natural areas of nearly heartbreaking beauty. But only a few of these already special public lands meet the rigorous criteria for a federal Wilderness designation.

The most truly wild and spectacular public lands deserve the highest form of protection the nation can offer. That’s why ELPC and our coalition partners are pursuing federal Wilderness designations for three particularly majestic areas of the Shawnee – Camp Hutchins, Ripple Hollow and Burke Branch.

Wilderness in Illinois

The 1964 Wilderness Act is one of the most important – and most poetic – pieces of legislation aimed at protecting America’s natural treasures.

“A wilderness, in contrast with those areas where man and his own works dominate the landscape, is hereby recognized as an area where the earth and its community of life are untrammeled by man, where man himself is a visitor who does not remain,” the act reads in part.

There are currently eight National Wilderness areas in Illinois, all in Southern Illinois. Seven of these are in the Shawnee National Forest; one is in the Crab Orchard National Wildlife Refuge near Carbondale. The seven Wilderness areas in the Shawnee were designated by the Illinois Wilderness Act of 1990 and are managed by the National Forest Service. The eighth area, Crab Orchard Wilderness, was designated by Congress in 1976 and is managed by the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service.

ELPC, in collaboration with conservation leaders across the state, has identified three sites in Illinois that meet federal standards for designation as new National Wilderness areas that would be worthy additions to the National Wilderness Preservation System: (1) Camp Hutchins, (2) Ripple Hollow, and (3) Burke Branch. Together, these three areas would add more than 12,000 acres of new Wilderness to the 289,000-acre Shawnee, bringing the total number of Wilderness areas within the forest to 10.

Meet The Areas

Existing and proposed Wilderness areas in Southern Illinois’ Shawnee National Forest.

Camp Hutchins, Ripple Hollow, and Burke Branch have been considered for Wilderness designation in the past, and they remain strong candidates today.

Camp Hutchins (2,967 acres)

Camp Hutchins is adjacent to two existing Wilderness areas: Bald Knob and Clear Springs. Camp Hutchins is also near the Trail of Tears State Forest and the LaRue-Pine Hills National Natural Landmark; the area around the latter is as biologically diverse as Great Smoky Mountains National Park. Though Camp Hutchins alone is only 2,967 acres, its designation would create a contiguous Wilderness area of roughly 20,000 acres due to its proximity to the abovementioned protected public lands. For this reason, Camp Hutchins would be a very valuable new Wilderness area for the state.

There have been efforts to designate Camp Hutchins as Wilderness dating back to 1977. The most recent effort occurred between 2004 and 2006 when the Forest Service prepared the Shawnee National Forest Land and Resource Management Plan (2006 Plan). The Sierra Club led this effort and worked with a coalition of groups called the Illinois Wilderness Action Network. Unfortunately, Camp Hutchins was not recommended for Wilderness designation at the time. While its proximity to Bald Knob and Clear Springs was a strength, two problems halted its being recommended: (1) Private land existed within Camp Hutchins, and (2) a county road separated the area from Bald Knob and Clear Springs. If the private land is acquired and the county road is closed, this site will be a strong candidate for National Wilderness designation.

Ripple Hollow (3,530 acres)

Ripple Hollow is roughly nine miles southwest of the McClure Shale Glade Nature Preserve. Though Ripple Hollow is less than 5,000 acres, it meets the criteria for Wilderness designation because of its unimpaired condition. The area has a large amount of old-growth forest and has resisted outside intrusion, with no improved or unimproved roads and no significant mining or logging history.

The roadless area analysis of the 1992 Forest Plan included a conditional Wilderness recommendation for Ripple Hollow pending procurement of the area’s private mineral rights. A private mining company owns the rights to silica found in Ripple Hollow, and there is no evidence that the mineral rights have been acquired from the mining company at present.

Illegal ATV use in the area is an immediate and ongoing threat to Ripple Hollow’s natural integrity. Unless Ripple Hollow receives protection soon, it could lose its wild and natural quality, robbing Illinois of one more valuable piece of its natural heritage. Therefore, it is essential that Ripple Hollow is preserved through the National Wilderness Preservation System so that it can be enjoyed for generations to come.

Burke Branch (6,230 acres)

Burke Branch near the Cretaceous Hills Nature Preserve is the largest of the three proposed Wilderness areas. Burke Branch was significantly logged in the past, but its roadless area designation in 1979 gave its forests a chance to regrow and close their canopy.

The 2006 Plan acknowledged Burke Branch as a large site with sensitive plant, water, and geological resources deserving protection. However, the Plan also noted that Burke Branch has a dense network of improved and unimproved roads.

Since 2006, Burke Branch has been managed primarily under the mature hardwood forest management prescription, which emphasizes wildlife habitat and recreation in a mature, hardwood-forest setting. This effective management has returned the area to a condition where it is again suitable for Wilderness consideration.

The Economic Case for Wilderness

In addition to the many natural and environmental benefits, Wilderness designation is a proven economic driver in Illinois. Wilderness recreation and passive-use contribute roughly $3.8 billion in wildlife recreation spending to the state’s economy. This spending supports roughly 204,000 jobs and generates nearly $1.6 billion annually in state and local tax revenue.

Private sector land management firms, which aid overstretched state and federal staffs, continue to create good, local jobs within their communities

A 2014 study published in the International Journal of Wilderness found that Wilderness designation reaps $9.4 billion a year – about $85 an acre – in benefits for the American public. These are benefits that stay stable even during economic downturns.

We benefit when we protect our lands. Environmentally, economically, socially, even spiritually. In the Midwest, our Wilderness is our bounty.

That’s why we are working with the public, policymakers, the conservation community, and elected officials to build support for adding Camp Hutchins, Ripple Hollow, and Burke Branch to the National Wilderness Preservation System. Our goal is to advance an action plan that will result in Congress designating these three areas in Illinois as new National Wilderness.

Tyler Barron,

Policy Advocate

Tyler Barron is a policy fellow at ELPC, working on Midwest climate change and clean energy solutions, and Great Lakes and natural resources protection advocacy issues.

MORE FROM Tyler Barron